Canadian Optimizer Logo

Amex SimplyCash Preferred Review: When the $119.88 Fee Pays for Itself

By AndrewPublished November 202611 min read
A card that charges $9.99 every month has to earn its place. We worked out the yearly spend at which Amex SimplyCash Preferred pays back its fee compared with Amex's own no-fee card, for three household budgets. This review from our cash back cards hub uses the earn rates on Amex's pages, read on November 14, 2026.
Amex SimplyCash Preferred Review: When the <div class= A card that charges $9.99 every month has to earn its place. We worked out the yearly spend at which Amex SimplyCash Preferred pays back its fee compared with Amex's own no-fee card, for three household budgets. This review from our cash back cards hub uses the earn rates on Amex's pages, read on November 14, 2026.
19.88 Fee Pays for Itself" class="post-featured-image" />

Amex SimplyCash Preferred is worth its $119.88 annual fee once you spend roughly $9,590 to $11,840 a year, depending on how much goes to groceries and gas. Below that, the no-fee Amex SimplyCash earns more. At $3,000 a month, the Preferred card's extra earnings beat its fee by $276.12.

Key takeaways:
  • The card earns 4% cash back at stand-alone gas stations and stand-alone grocery stores (groceries up to $30,000 a year, or $1,200 of cash back) and 2% on everything else, according to Amex.
  • The fee is $9.99 a month, or $119.88 a year, outside Quebec, and $119 a year in Quebec.
  • The extra cash back over the no-fee card is $180.00, $396.00 and $607.50 a year in our lean, typical and high budgets, so the net gain is $60.12, $276.12 and $487.62.
  • Superstores, wholesale clubs, alcohol retailers and general merchandise retailers do not earn the 4% rate, so check where you shop before you count on it.

How we compared it

We compared the SimplyCash Preferred with Amex's own no-fee SimplyCash card, so the only change between the two is the fee and the earn rates. We took each card's rates, caps and fee from Amex's pages on November 14, 2026, built three yearly budgets, multiplied the earn rate through each category, and solved for the yearly spend where the Preferred card's extra earnings equal its fee. The budgets are examples, not averages. We explain our method and the limits of AI help on how we use AI, and we have no affiliate link to this card, as set out on our disclosure page.

What does Amex SimplyCash Preferred pay?

It pays 4% on gas and groceries and 2% on everything else, with a yearly cap on the grocery rate. Amex's card page and benefits page state the rates and the credit schedule. The no-fee card has lower rates.

SimplyCash Preferred compared with SimplyCash (Amex pages, reviewed November 14, 2026)
SimplyCash PreferredSimplyCash (no annual fee)
Annual fee$9.99 a month ($119.88 a year); $119 in QuebecNone
Stand-alone gas stations4%2%
Groceries4% at stand-alone grocery stores, up to $30,000 of purchases ($1,200 cash back) a year2%, up to $300 of cash back (a $15,000 spend)
Everything else2%1.25%
Interest on purchases21.99%See Amex's page
Additional cardsNo annual feeSee Amex's page

Amex credits the cash back annually, on the September statement of each year, as long as the account is in good standing. That is a long wait compared with a monthly credit, and the cash back is not available until it posts. Our annual fee vs no-fee guide covers the general rule: a fee pays only if the extra rewards exceed it, which is what the next section tests.

What is the break-even spend against the fee?

The break-even depends on the mix. In a lean budget with 30% of spending on groceries and 10% on gas, the Preferred card pays back its fee at $9,590 a year ($799 a month). In a high-spending budget with only 15% on groceries and 6% on gas, it takes $11,840 a year. The reason is that the Preferred card beats the no-fee card by 0.75 points on everything else and by 2 points on groceries and gas, so a household with fewer groceries and gas needs more total spend to cover the fee.

SimplyCash Preferred against SimplyCash for three household budgets, all spend in Canada at stand-alone stores (our calculation; examples)
BudgetYearly spendMixPreferred cash backNo-fee cash backExtra before feeNet after $119.88 feeBreak-even yearly spend
Lean$14,40030% groceries, 10% gas$403.20$223.20$180.00+$60.12$9,590 ($799 a month)
Typical$36,00020% groceries, 8% gas$921.60$525.60$396.00+$276.12$10,898 ($908 a month)
High$60,00015% groceries, 6% gas$1,452.00$844.50$607.50+$487.62$11,840 ($987 a month)

Did you know: our own calculation shows the Preferred card's $119.88 fee is covered at $9,590 to $11,840 of yearly spend, depending on the mix, and that even a lean $1,200-a-month budget nets $60.12 more than the no-fee card.

Net yearly gain over the no-fee SimplyCash, after the Preferred card's $119.88 fee

Lean
$60.12
Typical
$276.12
High
$487.62

Example: the typical budget, line by line (illustration)

Spending $3,000 a month is $36,000 a year. Groceries at 20% are $7,200, gas at 8% is $2,880, and everything else is $25,920.

Preferred card: $7,200 × 4% = $288.00, plus $2,880 × 4% = $115.20, plus $25,920 × 2% = $518.40, for $921.60. After the $119.88 fee, $801.72.

No-fee card: $7,200 × 2% = $144.00, plus $2,880 × 2% = $57.60, plus $25,920 × 1.25% = $324.00, for $525.60.

What fine print moves the maths?

Four things can move the result, and all of them are in Amex's own terms.

  • Where you buy groceries. The 4% applies to stand-alone grocery stores. Amex lists superstores, wholesale clubs, alcohol retailers and general merchandise retailers among the retailers that do not qualify for it, so those purchases earn 2%. Every $3,600 of groceries moved from a stand-alone store to a superstore costs $72 (2% of $3,600) a year.
  • The grocery cap. The 4% stops at $30,000 of grocery purchases, worth $1,200 of cash back. Our budgets never reach it.
  • The payout timing. The cash back arrives once a year on the September statement.
  • Interest. The purchase rate is 21.99%. A balance carried for long enough costs more than the fee. At that rate, $1,000 carried for a year costs about $220 of interest.

The card page also lists insurance and Instacart statement credits among its benefits. Those depend on terms we did not price, so we did not count them. If you want to see how groceries fit in the broader market, our grocery card comparison and Costco card guide cover the stores Amex excludes.

How do you find your own break-even?

You need two numbers from your last twelve months of statements: how much you spent at stand-alone grocery stores and stand-alone gas stations, and how much you spent in total. The Preferred card earns 2 points of cash back more than the no-fee card on the first two and 0.75 points more on everything else, so the extra earnings are 2% of your groceries and gas plus 0.75% of the rest. If that sum is more than $119.88, the fee is covered.

  1. Add up the last twelve months of spending at stand-alone grocery stores, up to $30,000. Multiply by 2%.
  2. Add up spending at stand-alone gas stations. Multiply by 2%.
  3. Subtract both from your total spending, and multiply what is left by 0.75%.
  4. Add the three results and compare with $119.88.
  5. If you shop at superstores or wholesale clubs, leave those purchases out of step 1 and count them in step 3, because they earn the base rate.

The formula uses the no-fee card's rates as they appear on Amex's page, including its $300 grocery cash-back cap, which is a $15,000 spend. A household that spends more than $15,000 a year at stand-alone grocers gains a little more from the Preferred card than the 2-point shortcut shows, because the no-fee card's grocery rate falls after the cap. Our credit card rewards calculator can do the same sum with your own categories.

What else comes with the card?

Amex's pages list several extras: a referral bonus of up to $750 of cash back a year, free additional cards, mobile device insurance, travel insurance and Instacart statement credits of up to $60 within a 12-month period until December 31, 2027. We left all of them out of the maths. The referral bonus depends on other people, and the insurance depends on terms and exclusions on Amex's own insurance pages that we did not review for this article. If you value a feature in this list, read its terms before you apply. A feature you will not use is not a reason to pay the fee.

Who should pick it? Picks by buyer type

Pick it if your household spends about $800 to $990 a month or more, with groceries and gas at stand-alone stores. Skip it if you spend less, shop mainly at superstores or warehouse clubs, or would rather have no fee.

Picks by buyer type (our reading of the numbers above; no affiliate links)
BuyerPickWhyAlternative to compare
Lean household: about $1,200 a month, groceries and gas at stand-alone storesSimplyCash Preferred is ahead by a small marginNets $60.12 more than the no-fee card, with a break-even of $799 a monthBest no-annual-fee cards
Typical household: $3,000 a monthSimplyCash PreferredNets $276.12 more than the no-fee cardBest cash-back cards
High spender: $5,000 a monthSimplyCash Preferred, then compare a points cardNets $487.62 more than the no-fee card; points cards can beat it if you redeem wellCash back vs travel rewards

The no-fee Amex SimplyCash stays the right pick if you spend well under $799 a month or hate paying a fee. A points card can beat both for the right buyer; our Scotiabank Gold American Express review runs the same maths on the dining-and-travel side.

What is the welcome offer today?

As of November 14, 2026, Amex's page shows up to $200 in bonus cash back, from 10% cash back on up to $2,000 of purchases in the first 3 months, plus a $50 statement credit for a purchase in month 13, which it describes as up to $250 in bonus value. Amex says current or former cardmembers with this card are not eligible, and other terms apply. Amex says the offer is subject to change at any time, so read the offer on the page you are on. We did not include the offer in any figure above, because it is one-time and the fee is yearly. Our welcome bonus math shows how to value a bonus against the spend it needs.

Frequently asked questions

How much is the Amex SimplyCash Preferred annual fee?

It is $9.99 a month, which equals $119.88 a year, for non-Quebec residents, and $119 a year for Quebec residents, according to Amex's card page.

How much do I need to spend for the fee to be worth it?

About $9,590 to $11,840 a year in our three example budgets, compared with the no-fee Amex SimplyCash. The lower the share of groceries and gas in your spending, the higher the break-even.

What earns 4% cash back?

Purchases at stand-alone gas stations and stand-alone grocery stores in Canada. Groceries are capped at $30,000 of purchases a year, which is $1,200 of cash back.

Does Costco or Walmart earn the 4% grocery rate?

No. Amex says superstores and wholesale clubs do not qualify for the grocery accelerator, so those purchases earn the base rate, which is 2%.

When is the cash back paid?

Annually. Amex says it appears as a credit on the September statement, as long as your account is in good standing.

Is there an Amex card with no annual fee?

Yes. Amex SimplyCash has no annual fee and earns 2% on gas, 2% on groceries up to $300 of cash back and 1.25% on everything else, per Amex's page.

Is the Preferred card worth it if I carry a balance?

No. The purchase rate is 21.99%, so interest on a carried balance costs more than the cash back pays. Cash-back cards only make sense when you pay in full.

Sources

Related reading

Cash Back vs Travel Rewards Credit Cards in Canada: What Each Is Worth
Credit Cards

Cash Back vs Travel Rewards Credit Cards in Canada: What Each Is Worth

We priced a cash-back card against a travel-points card at $1,500, $3,000 and $5,000 a month. Cash back wins by up to $60.12 a year unless points are worth over 1.04¢.

Andrew·2026-11-17
Best Credit Card for Costco in Canada: The Mastercard-Only Math
Credit Cards

Best Credit Card for Costco in Canada: The Mastercard-Only Math

Costco warehouses take Mastercard, not Visa or American Express. As of September 2026 the CIBC Costco card is $0 and earns 1% in the warehouse.

Andrew·2026-09-27
Best Credit Cards for Groceries in Canada (2026)
Credit Cards

Best Credit Cards for Groceries in Canada (2026)

As of September 2026, Cobalt earns 5 points per dollar on stand-alone groceries, Scotia Momentum earns 4 percent at Visa grocery merchants, and PC World Elite states 3 percent in points at participating stores.

Andrew·2026-09-27