Canadian Optimizer Logo

GIC vs HISA: Where Your Cash Should Sit in Canada

By AndrewPublished November 202610 min read
Cash in a savings account can leave tomorrow; cash in a GIC usually cannot. That one difference, access, is worth less than most people think when the money already has a date attached, and more than they think when it does not. This comparison, part of our savings accounts, GICs and cash hub, puts after-tax numbers on it with rates read on November 18, 2026.
GIC vs HISA: Where Your Cash Should Sit in Canada

Choose a GIC for money with a fixed date one to five years away, and a high-interest savings account (HISA) for money you may need any day. As of November 2026, EQ Bank paid 3.70% on a one-year GIC and 4.25% on five years, against 1.50% (3.00% with direct deposits) on its savings account.

Key takeaways:
  • On $20,000 for three years, EQ's 4.00% GIC earns about $2,497 before tax, against $914 at a flat 1.50% savings rate (our calculation).
  • Interest from both is fully taxable outside a registered account, and the CRA says you must report GIC interest each year as it is earned, even if it is paid at maturity.
  • EQ Bank's GICs are non-redeemable: you cannot get the money back early.
  • GICs and savings deposits at a CDIC member are covered up to $100,000 per insured category, including interest.

How we compared GICs and HISAs

We read EQ Bank's rates page (rates effective November 18, 2026) for GIC and savings rates, RBC's posted personal account rates for a big-bank savings comparison, the CRA's line 12100 page for how interest is taxed, and CDIC's coverage page, all on November 18, 2026. We used one online bank's GIC and savings rates side by side so that the comparison is about the product, not about which bank is having a sale.

We then put an illustrative $20,000 into each option for one, three and five years, and applied two example marginal tax rates, 30% and 45%, to the interest. GIC interest compounds once a year; savings rates are held flat for the whole term, which is the biggest assumption on this page because savings rates can change at any time. No bank paid for placement, and there are no affiliate links. Our method is on how we use AI; our disclosure page explains how we make money.

What is the difference between a GIC and a HISA?

A guaranteed investment certificate (GIC) locks your money for a set term at a fixed rate; a high-interest savings account (HISA) lets you withdraw any time, at a rate the bank can change without notice. You trade access for a known, usually higher, rate.

GIC vs HISA at a glance (EQ Bank, RBC, CRA and CDIC pages, reviewed November 18, 2026)
FeatureGICHigh-interest savings account
RateFixed for the term (EQ: 3.70% for 1 year to 4.25% for 5 years)Variable (EQ: 1.50%, or 3.00% with direct deposits; RBC posted 0.650%)
AccessAt maturity; EQ's GICs are non-redeemableAny time (notice accounts: after 10 or 30 days)
Interest paidYearly or at maturity, depending on the GICCalculated daily, paid monthly
Tax outside a registered accountReport each year as earnedReport each year as received
CDIC coverageEligible depositEligible deposit
Best forMoney with a fixed dateEmergency fund, money with no date

EQ's short GICs fill the gap between the two: 2.65% for 3 months, 2.90% for 6 months and 3.30% for 9 months. A six-month GIC at 2.90% pays less than the 3.00% on EQ's 30 Day Notice Savings Account, so for short periods the notice account gives you a higher rate without the lock.

Which earns more after tax?

A GIC earns more after tax at every term we tested, as long as the savings rate stays where it is today. The gap is largest against a big-bank savings rate and smallest against a savings account paying a direct-deposit bonus.

After-tax interest on $20,000: EQ GIC vs savings accounts, at 30% and 45% example marginal tax rates (our calculation from rates read November 18, 2026; savings rates held flat)
TermEQ GIC rateGIC, 30% taxSavings at 1.50%, 30% taxSavings at 3.00%, 30% taxGIC, 45% taxSavings at 1.50%, 45% taxSavings at 3.00%, 45% tax
1 year3.70%$518$210$420$407$165$330
3 years4.00%$1,748$639$1,298$1,374$502$1,020
5 years4.25%$3,239$1,082$2,230$2,545$850$1,752
Example: $20,000 for a down payment in three years (illustration)
EQ 3-year GIC at 4.00%, compounded yearly$2,497
EQ savings at 3.00% held flat, compounded yearly$1,855
EQ savings at 1.50% held flat$914
RBC High Interest eSavings at 0.650% held flat$393
GIC advantage over 1.50% savings, before tax$1,584

At a 30% marginal rate, the GIC leaves about $1,748 after tax over three years, against $1,298 at 3.00% savings and $639 at 1.50%. If the money is in a TFSA or FHSA, there is no tax on either, and the before-tax figures apply.

The savings-rate assumption cuts both ways. If savings rates rise, the HISA catches up; if they fall, the GIC's fixed rate looks better still. A GIC removes that uncertainty for the term, which is the point when the money has a job on a known date.

Did you know: big-bank promotions can beat a GIC for a few months. RBC's savings page advertises a bonus rate for 90 days on a new High Interest eSavings account, after which balances earn the posted regular rate, which was 0.650% on November 18, 2026. Over a full year, the regular rate is what you mostly earn.

How is GIC and HISA interest taxed?

Both are taxed as interest income at your full marginal rate, reported on line 12100 of your return. The CRA says that for most investments made in 1990 or later you must report the interest each year as it is earned, even if a multi-year GIC pays it only at maturity.

That rule matters for compound GICs. With a three-year GIC that pays everything at the end, you still report the first year's interest, about $800 on our $20,000 example at 4.00%, on the return for the year it was earned. The CRA also says you must report interest even if you did not receive a T5 slip, which banks may not issue for amounts under $50.

Holding either in a Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) removes the tax. EQ Bank shows the same GIC rates for TFSA, RRSP and FHSA GICs as for non-registered ones, and pays 1.75% on its TFSA, FHSA and RRSP cash savings accounts. Our Canadian cash management guide covers which account to use for which cash.

Watch out: a non-redeemable GIC cannot be broken for an emergency. EQ Bank's GICs are non-redeemable, so never put your emergency fund in one. Keep the emergency fund in a savings account and put only money with a date in GICs.

Are GICs and HISAs both insured?

Yes, when they are held at a CDIC member. CDIC lists GICs and deposits as eligible, and insures each category (deposits in one name, joint deposits, TFSA, RRSP, RRIF, FHSA and others) separately up to $100,000, including principal and interest.

Include the interest when you add up a category: a GIC that grows past $100,000 by maturity is only covered up to the limit. EQ Bank says deposits made under EQ Bank and Equitable Bank share one CDIC limit per insured category, per depositor. HISA exchange-traded funds are a different product with different risks; our HISA vs cash ETF comparison covers them.

Can you get both? The ladder and the split

Yes. Most people should split their cash: a HISA for the emergency fund and near-term spending, and GICs for money with dates. A GIC ladder, with equal amounts maturing every year, gives a fixed rate on most of the money while one rung comes free each year.

  1. List your cash by job: emergency fund, known expenses with dates, and money with no date.
  2. Keep the emergency fund in a HISA you can reach the same week.
  3. For each dated expense, pick a GIC term that ends before the date.
  4. For money with no date that you will not touch for years, consider a ladder across 1 to 5 years.
  5. Check CDIC limits per category, and split across banks above $100,000.
  6. Recheck rates on the day you buy, and again before each GIC matures.
  • Emergency fund in an account you can reach any time
  • Each GIC term ends before the money is needed
  • TFSA or FHSA room used first for taxable interest
  • Interest from compound GICs reported every year
  • CDIC limit checked, including interest

Our GIC ladder guide shows how to build one step by step, and the emergency fund guide covers how big the HISA part should be.

Where should your cash sit?

Pick by when you need the money. Each pick shows a non-affiliate route; we link to no bank sign-up page.

GIC or HISA picks by situation (our calculation and reading of EQ Bank, RBC, CRA and CDIC pages, reviewed November 18, 2026; no affiliate links)
If the money is for…PickWhyNot for you if…Also consider
An emergency fundHigh-interest savings accountWithdraw any time; at EQ 1.50%, or 3.00% with direct depositsYou keep far more than three to six months of spending in cashOur EQ Bank review
A purchase 1–3 years awayA GIC whose term ends before the dateFixed rate; $1,748 after 30% tax on $20,000 over 3 years in our exampleThe date might move earlierA cashable GIC from your bank, if it offers one
Retirement income over several yearsA GIC ladder plus a HISA bufferOne rung matures each year; the HISA covers the gap monthsYou need growth beyond fixed incomeOur GIC ladder guide

When to get help: if you are deciding between GICs, paying down a mortgage and investing in a TFSA or RRSP, a fee-only planner or a tax professional can work out the after-tax answer for your own marginal rate.

Frequently asked questions

Is a GIC better than a high-interest savings account?

For money with a fixed date, usually yes: EQ Bank's one-year GIC paid 3.70% against 1.50% on its savings account as of November 2026. For an emergency fund, no, because you cannot cash a non-redeemable GIC early.

Can you lose money in a GIC?

Not at a CDIC member within the limit. CDIC covers GICs up to $100,000 per insured category, including interest. The real cost is lost access and inflation over the term.

Do I pay tax on GIC interest every year?

Yes, outside a registered account. The CRA says interest on most investments made in 1990 or later must be reported each year as it is earned, even if it is paid at maturity.

Is HISA interest taxable in Canada?

Yes. It is interest income reported on line 12100, unless the account is a TFSA, RRSP or FHSA.

What happens if I need GIC money early?

With a non-redeemable GIC, such as EQ Bank's, you cannot get it back before maturity. Cashable GICs exist at some banks, usually at a lower rate.

Should I put my emergency fund in a GIC?

No. Keep it in a savings account you can reach any time, and use GICs only for money with a known date.

Are GICs and HISAs covered by CDIC?

Yes, at CDIC member institutions, up to $100,000 per insured category, per institution, including principal and interest.

Sources

Related reading

EQ Bank Review: Personal Account, GICs and Transfers
Budgeting & Saving

EQ Bank Review: Personal Account, GICs and Transfers

EQ Bank pays 1.50% on its Personal Account, or 3.00% with $2,000 a month of direct deposits, with no everyday fees. Here are its rates, limits, GICs and trade-offs.

Andrew·2026-11-19
Canadian Cash Management Guide: HISAs, GICs, Cash ETFs, and T-Bills
Budgeting & Saving

Canadian Cash Management Guide: HISAs, GICs, Cash ETFs, and T-Bills

In September 2026 the Bank of Canada target is 2.25%. Park cash in a deposit, a GIC, or a cash ETF only after you know the date you need it.

Andrew·2026-09-27
Best High-Interest Savings Accounts in Canada (2026): Ongoing Rates vs Promos
Budgeting & Saving

Best High-Interest Savings Accounts in Canada (2026): Ongoing Rates vs Promos

EQ Bank’s Personal Account pays 1.50%, or 3.00% with $2,000 of monthly pay deposits, effective 3 November 2026. A teaser that expires is a different product from an ongoing rate with a printed hurdle.

Andrew·2026-09-27